In recent years, the usage of AI has increased significantly. According to the survey, 55% of Americans regularly use AI, and 44% do not use AI regularly. Using AI tools for image post-processing is becoming popular. Most photographers and eCommerce owners are confused about which is better to remove background by hand or with AI.
In this article, we are going to answer this question by comparing the advantages and disadvantages of both methods. Overall, you will get a crystal clear answer to follow the better method. This is going to be highly beneficial for photographers, eCommerce owners, and online sellers.
Background Removal By Hand Vs AI Background Removal: Which Is Better in 2024?
Background Removal By Hand
Background removal by hand involves using photo editing software like Adobe Photoshop to separate the subject from its background. This process is done by skilled professionals who have an in-depth knowledge of image editing. Professional Background Removal Service Provider use the pen tool to create a Clipping Path for perfect background removal.
As the process is manual, it provides an accurate result for background removal. It can handle any type of object and super complex shapes. The pen tool in Photoshop is suitable for isolating any objects with the highest accuracy.
AI Background Removal
AI background removal uses advanced algorithms and machine learning to automatically detect and remove backgrounds from images. This technology has become increasingly popular due to its speed and convenience. No additional image editing software is required to perform this process. You just need to upload the image and wait for a while.
AI tools remove the background automatically using their algorithm. As the process is automatic, there is not much option available for customization. It can remove the background cleanly for super easy objects like books. When the object has a difficult shape, it loses its accuracy.
Now, we are going to have a look at their comparisons based on different criteria. Here are the advantages and disadvantages of Manual Background removal. It will give you a better idea of how you should approach removing the background of your images.
Advantages of Background Removal By Hand
Precision and Accuracy
Hand-drawn background removal by experts offers the highest accuracy for all objects. A skilled editor can create paths around the object to ensure that every detail is captured. It ensures the background is cleanly removed. This level of accuracy is particularly important for images with complex edges.
Customization
When removing backgrounds by hand, editors have complete control over the process. They can make adjustments as needed. It ensures the final image meets specific requirements. This customization is highly important for projects like product photography and product advertisement.
Handling Complex Images
Images with difficult complex shapes and group photos can be handled perfectly by hand-drawn editing. Manual editing allows for a precise approach to covering complex shapes with accuracy.
Professional Quality
The human touch of expert editors produces a higher-quality result. A skilled designer can use his judgment to enhance the image, adjust colors, and ensure that the object looks perfect to attract everyone.
Disadvantages Of Background Removal By Hand
Time-Consuming
Manual background removal is a time-consuming process. Depending on the complexity of the image, it will take some time to achieve the desired result. However, a Professional Image Editing Company like Clipping Way can handle around 3500-5000 images per day.
Cost
Because it requires skilled professionals, manual background removal will cost you some amount. Typically, the cost is not that much considering the quality. Clipping charges are $0.25 per image only to remove the background with a money back guarantee.
Skill-Dependent
The quality of manual background removal depends on the skill of the editor. If you want to outsource the background removal service, you need to choose a skilled and trustworthy background removal service provider. Clipping Way is highly recommended for you.
At this point, we are going to inform you about the advantages and disadvantages of Background Removal By AI. It will assist you to make the final decision about choosing between manual background removal vs AI Background Removal.
Advantages of Background Removal By AI
Speed
AI can remove backgrounds in a matter of seconds. This speed is valuable for projects with tight deadlines that need to be processed quickly. But sometimes you may face limit issues as most of the AI background removal has daily limits.
Easy To Use
Most AI tools are user-friendly. This accessibility means that even those without having any knowledge of image editing can use the tools. No additional image editing tools are required to perform this action.
Disadvantages of Background Removal By AI
Accuracy Issues
While AI has come a long way, it still struggles with complex images and difficult shapes. Objects with fine details or similar colors to the background may not be accurately separated. If you are going to use the image for commercial purposes, it doesn’t have the accuracy to compete with others.
Lack of Customization
AI tools offer limited customization. If the initial result is not satisfactory, there won’t be any option to adjust it to perfection. This limitation can be frustrating for projects that require specific requirements.
Fail To Handle Super Complex Images
AI has difficulty with images that have soft edges and challenging elements that blend into the background. In such cases, you won’t be able to rely on AI Background removal to fulfill your needs.
Lack Of Consistency
The quality of AI background removal varies based on the tool used. Some tools may produce decent results for easy objects. Sometimes it will show inaccurate results for similar types of objects.
Sum Up
At this stage, we can say based on the above comparison it is always better to remove background by Hand manually than using AI. That’s the ultimate answer to the question of whether it is better to remove background by Hand or with AI. For professional and commercial use, image quality is the most important factor to consider. Manual Background Removal is the best solution to that.
If you need assistance with background removal or Clipping Path, don’t hesitate to outsource your image editing requirements to Clipping Way and get the best possible result for background removal.
FAQ’s
Which method is more accurate for removing backgrounds?
Manual Background Removal using Photoshop is the most accurate method to remove the background. It allows for precise editing while AI tools can miss fine details.
Is AI background removal faster than manual hand-drawn editing?
Yes, AI background removal is generally much faster. It completes tasks in seconds that might take manual editors much longer time.
Do AI background removal tools work well with complex images?
AI tools struggle with removing background from complex images. When the object has sharp details, AI tools fail to remove the background with perfection.
Can manual background removal handle any type of image?
Yes, Professional Background Removal Service Providers can handle all types of images. You can get the perfect result for most complex backgrounds.
Which method is more cost-effective to remove the background?
When you have got bulk images, choosing a Professional Image Editing Company will be a cost-effective option to remove the background with accuracy.
